Stabbeurfou adjudicator test report
|
Set of test cases |
Result |
|
|
Hasbro 2000 rules |
Compliant in all cases (as taken from diagrams) |
|
|
Descartes 1994 rules (French) |
Compliant in all cases (as taken from examples) except following case (XIII/A6-2): |
|
|
Descartes |
Stabbeurfou |
|
|
ALLEMAGNE A DAN - LONF NRD C A DAN - LON A YOR S A DAN - LON
ANGLETERRE A COR - BELF EDI - NRD;(failed) F GRO S F EDI - NRD F LON S F MAN;(dislodged) F MAN C A COR - BEL A PIC S A COR - BEL
FRANCE F ATL S F BRE - MAN F BEL S Allemand F NRD;(dislodged) F BRE – MAN;(failed)
(Fleets in BEL and LON are dislodged but have provided support) |
ALLEMAGNE A DAN - LON;(failed) F NRD C A DAN - LON A YOR S A DAN - LON
ANGLETERRE A COR - BEL;(failed) F EDI - NRD;(failed) F GRO S F EDI - NRD F LON S F MAN;(paradox) F MAN C A COR - BEL A PIC S A COR - BEL
FRANCE F ATL S F BRE - MAN F BEL S Allemand F NRD;(paradox) F BRE - MAN;(failed)
(Szykman adjudication) |
|
|
DATC 6.A. TEST CASES, BASIC CHECKS |
Compliant in all cases All cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) |
|
|
DATC 6.B. TEST CASES, TEST CASES, COASTAL ISSUES |
Compliant in all cases to choices 4.B.1 = a; 4.B.2 = a; 4.B.3 = b; 4.B.4 = a (this latest different from DATC). All cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) except 6.B.2 , 6.B.4 , 6.B.6 , 6.B.8, 6.B.9 and 6.B.13. |
|
|
DATC 6.C. TEST CASES, CIRCULAR MOVEMENT |
Compliant in all cases. |
|
|
DATC 6.D. TEST CASES, SUPPORTS AND DISLODGES |
Compliant in all cases to choice 4.E.1 = d Following cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) : 6.D.22 , 6.D.23 , 6.D.24 , 6.D.28 , 6.D.29 , 6.D.30 , 6.D.31 , 6.D.32 and 6.D.34. |
|
|
DATC 6.E. TEST CASES, HEAD TO HEAD BATTLES AND BELEAGUERED GARRISON |
Compliant in all cases to choices 4.E.1 = d |
|
|
DATC 6.F. TEST CASES, TEST CASES, CONVOYS |
Compliant in all cases to choices 4.A.1 = b and 4.A.2 = d |
|
|
DATC 6.G. TEST CASES, CONVOYING TO ADJACENT PLACES |
Compliant in all cases to 4.A.7 = b and 4.A.3=c (this latest different from DATC)
More precisely :
|
|
|
DATC 6.H. TEST CASES, RETREATING |
Compliant in all cases to choice 4.A.3 = c (this latest different from DATC) Following case provoke an error (orders are rejected) : 6.H.11 and 6.H.12 since retreat is not allowed to what is considered as the origin of the attack. |
|
|
DATC 6.I. TEST CASES, BUILDING |
Compliant in all cases to choice 4.C.3 = c All cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) since builds are not correct. |
|
|
DATC 6.J. TEST CASES, CIVIL DISORDER AND DISBANDS |
Compliant in all cases to choices 4.D.8 = d except that Stabbeurfou uses the three letter code for the name of the region. Following case provoke an error (orders are rejected) : 6.J.1 and 6.J.2 since disbands are not correct. |
|