Stabbeurfou adjudicator test report



Set of test cases

Result

Hasbro 2000 rules

Compliant in all cases (as taken from diagrams)

Descartes 1994 rules (French)

Compliant in all cases (as taken from examples) except following case (XIII/A6-2):

Descartes

Stabbeurfou

ALLEMAGNE

A DAN - LON

F NRD C A DAN - LON

A YOR S A DAN - LON


ANGLETERRE

A COR - BEL

F EDI - NRD;(failed)

F GRO S F EDI - NRD

F LON S F MAN;(dislodged)

F MAN C A COR - BEL

A PIC S A COR - BEL


FRANCE

F ATL S F BRE - MAN

F BEL S Allemand F NRD;(dislodged)

F BRE – MAN;(failed)


(Fleets in BEL and LON are dislodged but have provided support)

ALLEMAGNE

A DAN - LON;(failed)

F NRD C A DAN - LON

A YOR S A DAN - LON


ANGLETERRE

A COR - BEL;(failed)

F EDI - NRD;(failed)

F GRO S F EDI - NRD

F LON S F MAN;(paradox)

F MAN C A COR - BEL

A PIC S A COR - BEL


FRANCE

F ATL S F BRE - MAN

F BEL S Allemand F NRD;(paradox)

F BRE - MAN;(failed)


(Szykman adjudication)

DATC 6.A. TEST CASES, BASIC CHECKS

Compliant in all cases

All cases provoke an error (orders are rejected)

DATC 6.B. TEST CASES, TEST CASES, COASTAL ISSUES

Compliant in all cases to choices 4.B.1 = a; 4.B.2 = a; 4.B.3 = b; 4.B.4 = a (this latest different from DATC).

All cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) except 6.B.2 , 6.B.4 , 6.B.6 , 6.B.8, 6.B.9 and 6.B.13.

DATC 6.C. TEST CASES, CIRCULAR MOVEMENT

Compliant in all cases.

DATC 6.D. TEST CASES, SUPPORTS AND DISLODGES

Compliant in all cases to choice 4.E.1 = d

Following cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) : 6.D.22 , 6.D.23 , 6.D.24 , 6.D.28 , 6.D.29 , 6.D.30 , 6.D.31 , 6.D.32 and 6.D.34.

DATC 6.E. TEST CASES, HEAD TO HEAD BATTLES AND BELEAGUERED GARRISON

Compliant in all cases to choices 4.E.1 = d

DATC 6.F. TEST CASES, TEST CASES, CONVOYS

Compliant in all cases to choices 4.A.1 = b and 4.A.2 = d

DATC 6.G. TEST CASES, CONVOYING TO ADJACENT PLACES

Compliant in all cases to 4.A.7 = b and 4.A.3=c (this latest different from DATC)


More precisely :

  • 6.G.1 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.2 :Not compliant to DATC preference. Units swap. Possible kidnapping.

  • 6.G.3 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.4 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.5 :Compliant to DATC preference, but not because of intent. Unit swap.

  • 6.G.6 Not compliant to DATC preference. Units swap. Possible kidnapping.

  • 6.G.7 : Not compliant to DATC preference. Units swap. Possible kidnapping.

  • 6.G.8 : Compliant to DATC preference.

  • 6.G.9 : Not compliant to DATC preference. Units do not swap.

  • 6.G.10 :Compliant to DATC preference. No head to head battle between SWE and NWY. So NRG is bounced.

  • 6.G.11 : Not compliant to DATC preference. SWE moves by land to NWY. NWY is dislodged and SKA is not.

  • 6.G.12 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.13 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.14 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.15 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.16 :Compliant to DATC preference

  • 6.G.17 : Not compliant to DATC preference. NWY moves by land to SWE. SWE is dislodged.

  • 6.G.18 :Compliant to DATC preference

DATC 6.H. TEST CASES, RETREATING

Compliant in all cases to choice 4.A.3 = c (this latest different from DATC)

Following case provoke an error (orders are rejected) : 6.H.11 and 6.H.12 since retreat is not allowed to what is considered as the origin of the attack.

DATC 6.I. TEST CASES, BUILDING

Compliant in all cases to choice 4.C.3 = c

All cases provoke an error (orders are rejected) since builds are not correct.

DATC 6.J. TEST CASES, CIVIL DISORDER AND DISBANDS

Compliant in all cases to choices 4.D.8 = d except that Stabbeurfou uses the three letter code for the name of the region.

Following case provoke an error (orders are rejected) : 6.J.1 and 6.J.2 since disbands are not correct.