Stabbeurfou adjudicator test report

Hasbro 2008 rules

MOVE 3	Italy F Rom - Ven	Compliant
MOVE 4	Germany A Ber - Sil Russia A War - Sil	Compliant
MOVE 5	Germany F Kie - Ber A Ber - Pru Russia A Pru H	Compliant
MOVE 6	Germany F Ber - Pru A Pru - Ber	Compliant
MOVE 7	England A Hol - Bel F Bel - NTH France F NTH - Hol	Compliant
MOVE 8	France A Mar - Bur A Gas S A Mar - Bur Germany A Bur H	Compliant
MOVE 9	Germany A Sil - Pru F BAL S A Sil - Pru Russia A Pru H	Compliant
MOVE 10	France F GOL - TYN F WES S F GOL - TYN Italy F Nap - TYN F Rom S F Nap - TYN	Compliant
MOVE 11	France F GOL - TYN F WES S F GOL - TYN Italy F TYN H F Rom S F TYN H	Compliant
MOVE 12	Austria A Boh - Mun A Tyr S A Boh - Mun Germany A Mun - Sil A Ber S A Mun - Sil Russia A War - Sil A Pru S A War - Sil	Compliant
MOVE 13	Turkey A Bul - Rum Russia A Rum - Bul A Ser S A Rum - Bul A Sev - Rum	Compliant
MOVE 14	Turkey A Bul - Rum F BLA S A Bul - Rum Russia A Rum - Bul A Gre S A Rum - Bul A Ser S A Rum - Bul A Sev - Rum	Compliant
MOVE 15	Germany A Pru - War A Sil S A Pru - War Russia A War H A Boh - Sil	Compliant
MOVE 16	Germany A Pru - War A Sil S A Pru - War Russia A War - Sil	Compliant
MOVE 17	Germany F Ber - Pru A Sil S F Ber - Pru Russia A Pru - Sil A War S A Pru - Sil F BAL - Pru	Compliant
MOVE 18	Germany A Ber H A Mun - Sil Russia A Pru - Ber A Sil S A Pru - Ber A Boh - Mun A Tyr S A Boh - Mun	Compliant
CONVOY 19	England A Lon - Nwy F NTH C A Lon - Nwy	Compliant
CONVOY 20	England A Lon - Tun F ENG C A Lon - Tun F MID C A Lon - Tun France F WES C English A Lon - Tun	Compliant
RARE CASE 21	France A Spa - Nap F GOL C A Spa - Nap F TYN C A Spa - Nap Italy F ION - TYN F Tun S F ION - TYN	Compliant
RARE CASE 22	France A Par - Bur A Mar S A Par - Bur A Bur H	Compliant
RARE CASE 23	France A Par - Bur A Bur - Mar Germany A Ruh S French A Par - Bur Italy A Mar - Bur	Compliant
RARE CASE 24	Germany A Ruh - Bur A Mun H France A Par S German A Ruh - Bur A Bur H	Compliant
RARE CASE 25	Germany A Mun - Tyr A Ruh - Mun A Sil - Mun Austria A Tyr - Mun A Boh S German A Sil - Mun	Compliant
RARE CASE 26	England F Den - Kie F NTH - Den F HEL S F NTH - Den Russia A Ber - Kie F SKA - Den F BAL S F SKA - Den	Compliant
RARE CASE 27	Austria A Ser - Bud A Vie - Bud Russia A Gal S Austrian A Ser - Bud	Compliant
RARE CASE 28	England A Lon - Bel F NTH C A Lon - Bel France A Bel - Lon F ENG C A Bel - Lon	Compliant
RARE CASE 29	England A Lon - Bel F ENG C A Lon - Bel F NTH C A Lon - Bel France F Bre - ENG F IRI S F Bre - ENG	Compliant
RARE CASE 30	France A Tun - Nap F TYN C A Tun - Nap Italy F ION - TYN F Nap S F ION - TYN	Compliant
RARE CASE 31	France A Tun - Nap F TYN C A Tun - Nap F ION C A Tun - Nap Italy F Rom - TYN F Nap S F Rom - TYN	Compliant
RARE CASE 32	France A Tun - Nap F TYN C A Tun - Nap F ION C A Tun - Nap A Apu S A Tun - Nap Italy F Rom - TYN F Nap S F Rom - TYN	Compliant

Descartes 1994 rules (French)

Compliant in all cases (as taken from examples) except following case (XIII/A6-2):

DESCARTES

STABBEURFOU

ALLEMAGNE

A DAN - LON

F NRD C A DAN - LON

A YOR S A DAN - LON

ANGLETERRE

A COR - BEL

F EDI - NRD;(failed)

F GRO S F EDI - NRD

F LON S F MAN;(dislodged)

F MAN C A COR - BEL

A PIC S A COR - BEL

FRANCE

F ATL S F BRE - MAN

F BEL S Allemand F NRD;(dislodged)

F BRE – MAN;(failed)

(Fleets in BEL and LON are dislodged but have provided support)

ALLEMAGNE

A DAN - LON;(failed)

F NRD C A DAN - LON

A YOR S A DAN - LON

ANGLETERRE

A COR - BEL;(failed)

F EDI - NRD;(failed)

F GRO S F EDI - NRD

F LON S F MAN;(paradox)

F MAN C A COR - BEL

A PIC S A COR - BEL

FRANCE

F ATL S F BRE - MAN

F BEL S Allemand F NRD;(paradox)

F BRE – MAN;(failed)

(Szykman adjudication)

DPTG examples

Test Case	Status
Example 1	Compliant
Example 2	Compliant
Example 3	Compliant
Example 4	Compliant
Example 5	Compliant
Example 6	Compliant
Example 7	Compliant
Example 8	Compliant
Example 9	Compliant
Example 10	Compliant
Example 11	Compliant
Example 12	Compliant
Example 13	Compliant
Example 14	Compliant
Example 15	Compliant
Example 16	Compliant
Example 17	Compliant
Example 18	Compliant
Example 19	Compliant
Example 20	Compliant
Example 21	Compliant

DATC test cases

Legend for DATC cases :

CO : Compliant to Official Diplomacy Rules

CP : Compliant to DATC preference

EO : Equivalent to Official Diplomacy Rules

EP : Equivalent to DATC preference

(R): The set of orders is rejected since one order is detected as invalid

(CD): Implemented when generating Civil Disorder Orders

NCO : NOT complaint to Official Diplomacy Rules

NCP : NOT Compliant to DATC preference

DATC 6.A. TEST CASES, BASIC CHECKS

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.A.1	EO (R)
6.A.2	EO (R)
6.A.3	EO (R)
6.A.4	EO (R)
6.A.5	EO (R)
6.A.6	EO (R)
6.A.7	EO (R)
6.A.8	EO (R)
6.A.9	EO (R)
6.A.10	EO (R)
6.A.11	CO
6.A.12	CO

DATC 6.B. TEST CASES, TEST CASES, COASTAL ISSUES

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.B.1	EP (R)
6.B.2	CP
6.B.3	EP (R)
6.B.4	CO
6.B.5	EO (R)
6.B.6	CO
6.B.7	NCP (R)	“F Portugal Supports F Mid-Atlantic Ocean – Spain”: Stabbeurfou rejects the order since the coast specification is missing
6.B.8	CP
6.B.9	NCP	Choice 4.B.4=e Any specification of coast in a support order is ignored at adjudication level (even if mandatory at verification level) “France: F Portugal Supports F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Spain(nc) F Mid-Atlantic Ocean - Spain(sc)”: Stabbeurfou issues a warning but grants the support even if coasts specification are different
6.B.10	NCP (R)	“France has a fleet on the south coast of Spain and orders: F Spain(nc) - Gulf of Lyon”: Stabbeurfou rejects the order since coast specification is erroneous.
6.B.11	EO (R)
6.B.12	NCP (R)	“A Gascony - Spain(nc)”: Stabbeurfou rejects the orders since no army may reach the north coast of Spain.
6.B.13	CO
6.B.14	EP (R)

DATC 6.C. TEST CASES, CIRCULAR MOVEMENT

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.C.1	CO
6.C.2	CO
6.C.3	CO
6.C.4	CO
6.C.5	CO
6.C.6	CO
6.C.7	CO

DATC 6.D. TEST CASES, SUPPORTS AND DISLODGES

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.D.1	CO
6.D.2	CO
6.D.3	CO
6.D.4	CO
6.D.5	CO
6.D.6	CO
6.D.7	CO
6.D.8	CO
6.D.9	CO
6.D.10	CO
6.D.11	CO
6.D.12	CO
6.D.13	CO
6.D.14	CO
6.D.15	CO
6.D.16	CO
6.D.17	CO
6.D.18	CO
6.D.19	CO
6.D.20	CO
6.D.21	CO
6.D.22	CO
6.D.23	EO (R)
6.D.24	EO (R)
6.D.25	CO
6.D.26	CO
6.D.27	CO
6.D.28	EO (R)
6.D.29	EP (R)
6.D.30	EP (R)
6.D.31	EP (R)
6.D.32	EP (R)
6.D.33	CO
6.D.34	EO (R)

DATC 6.E. TEST CASES, HEAD TO HEAD BATTLES AND BELEAGUERED GARRISON

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.E.1	CO
6.E.2	CO
6.E.3	CO
6.E.4	CO
6.E.5	CO
6.E.6	CO
6.E.7	CO
6.E.8	CO
6.E.9	CO
6.E.10	CO
6.E.11	CO
6.E.12	CO
6.E.13	CO
6.E.14	EO (R)
6.E.15	CO

DATC 6.F. TEST CASES, TEST CASES, CONVOYS

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.F.1	EO (R)
6.F.2	CO
6.F.3	CO
6.F.4	CO
6.F.5	CO
6.F.6	CO
6.F.7	CO
6.F.8	CO
6.F.9	CP
6.F.10	CP
6.F.11	CP
6.F.12	CO
6.F.13	CO
6.F.14	CP
6.F.15	CP
6.F.16	CO
6.F.17	CP
6.F.18	CP
6.F.19	CP
6.F.20	CP
6.F.21	CP
6.F.22	CP
6.F.23	CP
6.F.24	CP

DATC 6.G. TEST CASES, CONVOYING TO ADJACENT PLACES

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.G.1	CP
6.G.2	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. Army in Norway is convoyed and swaps its place with the fleet in Sweden
6.G.3	CP
6.G.4	CP
6.G.5	CP
6.G.6	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The English army in Liverpool moves by convoy and consequentially the two armies are swapped
6.G.7	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The army in Sweden moves by convoy and swaps places with the fleet in Norway
6.G.8	CP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The 'via Convoy' directive has no meaning and the army in Belgium moves to Holland
6.G.9	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The move of the army in Norway is by convoy and the armies in Norway and Sweden are swapped
6.G.10	CP
6.G.11	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The move from Sweden to Norway is not a convoy and the English fleet in Norway is dislodged and the fleet in Skagerrak is not dislodged.
6.G.12	CO
6.G.13	CP
6.G.14	CP
6.G.15	CP
6.G.16	CO
6.G.17	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. Norway takes the land route. Sweden has to retreat.
6.G.18	CO

DATC 6.H. TEST CASES, RETREATING

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.H.1	EO (R)
6.H.2	EO (R)
6.H.3	EO (R)
6.H.4	EO (R)
6.H.5	EO (R)
6.H.6	EO (R)
6.H.7	CO
6.H.8	CO
6.H.9	CO
6.H.10	CO
6.H.11	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The army in Gascony does not move with the use of the convoy, because the army in Marseilles does not move in opposite direction. This immediately means that the army in Marseilles may not move to Gascony when it dislodged by the army there.
6.H.12	NCP	Choice 4.A.3=c The land route is taken except when the unit in the target area moves in opposite direction and there is an undisrupted convoy route. The army in Liverpool does not try to move by convoy, because the convoy is disrupted. This has as consequence that the army just advances to Edinburgh by using the land route.
6.H.13	CO
6.H.14	CO
6.H.15	CO
6.H.16	CO

DATC 6.I. TEST CASES, BUILDING

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.I.1	EO (R)
6.I.2	EO (R)
6.I.3	EO (R)
6.I.4	EO (R)
6.I.5	EO (R)
6.I.6	EO (R)
6.I.7	EO (R)

DATC 6.J. TEST CASES, CIVIL DISORDER AND DISBANDS

Test Case	Status	Comment or explanation
6.J.1	EO (R)
6.J.2	EO (R)
6.J.3	EO (CD)
6.J.4	EO (CD)	Stabbeurfou uses for alphabetical order the three letter code instead of the full name.
6.J.5	NCP	Stabbeurfou uses a distance where fleet may go over land.
6.J.6	NCP	Stabbeurfou uses a distance where fleet may go over land.
6.J.7	CP (CD)	Stabbeurfou uses for alphabetical order the three letter code instead of the full name.
6.J.8	CP (CD)
6.J.9	CP (CD
6.J.10	CP (CD
6.J.11	CP (CD