Listed below, with explanations if different.
|
CHAP. |
NAME OF ISSUE |
DATC |
SF |
EXPLANATION |
|
CONVOY ISSUES |
||||
|
4.A.1 |
MULTI-ROUTE CONVOY DISRUPTION |
b |
b |
Compliant |
|
4.A.2 |
CONVOY DISRUPTION PARADOXES
|
d |
d |
Compliant |
|
4.A.3 |
CONVOYING TO ADJACENT PLACE |
d |
c |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» uses the land route first if unopposed, otherwise any successful convoy route. |
|
4.A.4 |
SUPPORT CUT ON ATTACK ON ITSELF VIA CONVOY |
a |
a |
Compliant. (Not relevant since 4.A.3=c) |
|
4.A.5 |
RETREAT WHEN DISLODGED BY CONVOY |
b |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» considers a move by convoy to be not different from a move by land on this matter. (Not relevant since 4.A.3=c) |
|
4.A.6 |
CONVOY PATH SPECIFICATION |
a |
a |
Compliant. Convoy path routes are rejected by «Stabbeurfou» which intends to find the route itself, not trying to find out the intent of the player in any way. Any road of convoy specified for an order of displacement of army from coast to coast will cause the refusal of the order by the system Any notation “by convoy” or related will be ignored |
|
4.A.7 |
AVOIDING A HEAD TO HEAD BATTLE TO BOUNCE A UNIT
|
b |
b |
Compliant. |
|
COASTAL ISSUES |
||||
|
4.B.1 |
OMITTED COAST SPECIFICATION IN MOVE ORDER WHEN TWO COASTS ARE POSSIBLE |
a |
a |
Compliant. |
|
4.B.2 |
OMITTED COAST SPECIFICATION IN MOVE ORDER WHEN ONE COAST IS POSSIBLE |
a |
a |
Compliant |
|
4.B.3 |
MOVE ORDER TO IMPOSSIBLE COAST |
b |
b |
Compliant. |
|
4.B.4 |
COAST SPECIFICATION IN SUPPORT ORDER |
d |
a/c |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» requires to specify coast in supported move when two coasts are possible. The movement (or support of a movement) towards an area with several coast, without the coast being specified, but for which only one is accessible for the unit (or the constant unit) is accepted, the system guesses the coast |
|
4.B.5 |
WRONG COAST OF ORDERED UNIT |
b |
a |
Not compliant since . «Stabbeurfou» rejects any wrong coast specification |
|
4.B.6 |
UNKNOWN COASTS OR IRRELEVANT COASTS |
b |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any coast specification if none is requested. |
|
4.B.7 |
COAST SPECIFICATION IN BUILD ORDER |
a |
a |
Compliant. |
|
UNIT DESIGNATION AND NATIONALITY ISSUES |
||||
|
4.C.1 |
MISSING UNIT DESIGNATION |
b |
a/b |
Half compliant. On «Stabbeurfou», unit designation is only mandatory for an active unit (the one ordered.) The type of unit may be omitted in all other cases, I.e. :
|
|
4.C.2 |
WRONG UNIT DESIGNATION |
b |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any order with any extra information that is inaccurate. |
|
4.C.3 |
MISSING UNIT DESIGNATION IN BUILD ORDER |
c |
c |
Compliant. |
|
4.C.4 |
BUILDING A FLEET IN A LAND AREA |
a |
a |
Compliant. |
|
TOO MANY AND TOO FEW ORDERS |
||||
|
4.D.1 |
MULTIPLE ORDER SETS WITH DEFINED ORDER |
c |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any set of order with any orders extra than that is requested. |
|
4.D.2 |
MULTIPLE ORDER SETS WITH UNDEFINED ORDER |
b |
N/A |
This may not happen with «Stabbeurfou» since there may not be several sets of orders. |
|
4.D.3 |
MULTIPLE ORDERS TO THE SAME UNIT |
c |
None |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any set of order with any order extra than that is requested. That also applies if a unit receives several same orders. |
|
4.D.4 |
TOO MANY BUILD ORDERS |
b |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any set of order with any order extra than that is requested. |
|
4.D.5 |
MULTIPLE BUILD ORDERS FOR ONE AREA |
b |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any set of order with any order extra than that is requested. |
|
4.D.6 |
TOO MANY DISBAND ORDERS |
b |
a |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any set of order with any order extra than that is requested. |
|
MISCELLANEOUS ISSUES |
||||
|
4.E.1 |
ILLEGAL ORDERS |
d |
d |
Compliant. A whimsical order of movement is refused by the system, therefore the problem to know if a defensive support holds or not on such a unit is not posed. |
|
4.E.2 |
POORLY WRITTEN ORDERS |
d |
None |
Not compliant since «Stabbeurfou» rejects any typing mistake |
|
4.E.3 |
IMPLICIT ORDERS |
b |
b |
Compliant. |
|
4.E.4 |
PERPETUAL ORDERS |
b |
b |
Compliant. Orders are erased after every adjudication. |
|
4.E.5 |
PROXY ORDERS |
c |
c |
Compliant. May not happen unless some password is given out. |
|
4.E.6 |
FLYING DUTCHMAN |
None |
None |
Almost completely compliant. Only last adjudication result may be fixed. May not happen unless bugs are involved. |
(a) If centre ownership table is the same after three consecutive diplomatic years, the game is stopped.
(b) A player is still part of a game as long as he controls a centre and/or a unit.
(c) The victory amounts in centres and not in units (there is a nuance, a player close to the absolute victory could miss free national centres to build.)
(e) One can contribute to dislodge a unit of one’s unit by convoying another unit. Although a certain logic wants to prohibit it, it is possible.
(f) An area of retreat forbidden by the fact of units of a player and only this player is also, to him, prohibited to retreat.
(g) Say that a defensively supported unit is trying to move by a not valid convoy (because one (or several) fleet(s) was (were) is dislodged or did not provide the convoy.) Displacement is tried thus the support is not valid.
(h) “H” to hold is not encouraged in an order of defensive support. The sequence “XXX” is refused by the system.
(i) The measurement of winning of game on majority of centres does not amount in the majority of the possessed centres, but in the majority of the existing centres. Thus, if a centre is always neutral, it is not enough to have 33/2 + 1 = 17 centres to win the game. The rule requires the possession of at least 18 centres for the absolute victory.
(a) Instead of being underlined, unsuccessful orders are changed to lower case.
Example for original order “A par s a mar – bur”:
Success : A par S a mar – bur
Failure : A par s a mar – bur
(b) Following conventions for the automatic reports of the orders are indicative and not compulsory.
|
NOTATION |
EXPLANATION |
|
A PAR s A BUR; (cut) |
The support was cut. |
|
F ENG c LON - BEL |
The convoy was broken. |
|
A PAR H; (destroyed) |
The unit was forced to retreat, then destroyed (no possible retreat). |
|
A PAR H; (dislodged) |
The unit was forced to retreat (dislodged). |
|
A PAR S A BUR ;(invalid) [A BUR - MUN] |
The support is not valid because provided to a unit which does not request it. |
|
F ENG C A BRE - LON ;(invalid) [A BRE - PAR] |
The convoy is not valid because provided to a unit which does not request it. |
|
A PAR - BUR; (failed) |
Displacement could not take place. It failed. |
|
A PAR S BUR; (paradox) |
The support for or against a convoying fleet is the target of a convoyed attack that may lead to a paradox… |
|
A PAR – BUR |
Displacement was carried out. |
|
A PAR r BUR; (failed) |
The retreat could not take place. It failed (collision with another retreat). |
|
A PAR R BUR |
The retreat was carried out. |
One will use the following tables to ensure oneself of a good comprehension of the geographical synonyms.
(a) International Hasbro map
|
INTERNATIONAL ABREV. |
NAMES OF THE AREA |
OTHER USUAL NAMES GIVEN |
INDICATIONS |
NATURE OF THE AREA |
|
ADR |
Adriatic Sea |
ADS |
|
Sea |
|
AEG |
Aegean Sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
ALB |
Albania |
|
|
Coast |
|
ANK |
Ankara |
|
(*/Turkey) |
Coast |
|
APU |
Apulia |
|
|
Coast |
|
ARM |
Armenia |
|
|
Coast |
|
BAL |
The Baltic Sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
BAR |
The Barents Sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
BEL |
Kingdom of Belgium |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
BER |
Berlin |
|
(*/Germany) |
Coast |
|
BLA |
Black Sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
BOH |
Bohemia |
|
|
Land |
|
BOT |
Gulf of Bothnia |
GOB |
|
Sea |
|
BRE |
Brest |
|
(*/France) |
Coast |
|
BUD |
Budapest |
|
(*/Austria) |
Land |
|
BUL |
Kingdom of Bulgaria |
“East coast” synonymous with “northern Coast” |
(*) |
Coast with two coasts |
|
BUR |
Burgundy |
|
|
Land |
|
CLY |
Clyde |
|
|
Coast |
|
CON |
Constantinople |
|
(*/Turkey) |
Coast |
|
DEN |
Kingdom of Denmark |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
EAS |
The Eastern Mediterranean Sea |
EMS |
|
Sea |
|
EDI |
Edinburgh |
|
(*/England) |
Coast |
|
ENG |
The English Channel |
|
|
Sea |
|
FIN |
Finland |
|
|
Coast |
|
GAL |
Galicia |
|
|
Land |
|
GAS |
Gascony |
|
|
Coast |
|
GOL |
Gulf of Lyon |
|
|
Sea |
|
GRE |
Kingdom of Greece |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
HEL |
Helgoland Bight |
|
|
Sea |
|
HOL |
Holland |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
ION |
Ionian sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
IRI |
The Irish Sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
KIE |
Kiel |
|
(*/Germany) |
Coast |
|
LON |
London |
|
(*/England |
Coast |
|
LVN |
Livonia |
|
|
Coast |
|
LVP |
Liverpool |
LPL |
(*/England) |
Coast |
|
MID |
Mid-Atlantic Ocean |
MAO |
|
Sea |
|
MAR |
Marseilles |
|
(*/France) |
Coast |
|
MOS |
Moscow |
|
(*/Russia) |
Land |
|
MUN |
Munich |
|
(*/Germany) |
Land |
|
NAT |
North Atlantic Ocean |
NAO |
|
Sea |
|
NAF |
North Africa |
|
|
Coast |
|
NAP |
Naples |
|
(*/Italy) |
Coast |
|
NRG |
Norwegian Sea |
NWG |
|
Sea |
|
NTH |
The North Sea |
|
|
Sea |
|
NWY |
Kingdom of Norway |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
PAR |
Paris |
|
(*/France) |
Land |
|
PIC |
Picardy |
|
|
Coast |
|
PIE |
Piedmont |
|
|
Coast |
|
POR |
Kingdom of Portugal |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
PRU |
Prussia |
|
|
Coast |
|
ROM |
Rome |
|
(*/Italy) |
Coast |
|
RUH |
Ruhr |
|
|
Land |
|
RUM |
Kingdom of Romania |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
SER |
Kingdom of Serbia |
|
(*) |
Land |
|
SEV |
Sevastopol |
|
(*/Russia) |
Coast |
|
SIL |
Silesia |
|
|
Land |
|
SKA |
Skagerak |
|
|
Sea |
|
SMY |
Smyrna |
|
(*/Turkey) |
Coast |
|
SPA |
Kingdom of Spain |
|
(*) |
Coast with two coasts |
|
STP |
Saint-Petersburg |
|
(*/Russia) |
Coast with two coasts |
|
SWE |
Kingdom of Sweden |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
SYR |
Syria |
|
|
Coast |
|
TRI |
Trieste |
|
(*/Austria) |
Coast |
|
TUN |
Tunis |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
TUS |
Tuscany |
|
|
Coast |
|
TYR |
Tyrolia |
|
|
Land |
|
TYN |
The Tyrrhenian Sea |
TYS |
|
Sea |
|
UKR |
Ukraine |
|
|
Land |
|
VEN |
Venice |
|
(*/Italy) |
Coast |
|
VIE |
Vienna |
|
(*/Austria |
Land |
|
WAL |
Wales |
|
|
Coast |
|
WAR |
Warsaw |
|
(*/Russia) |
Land |
|
WES |
The Western Mediterranean Sea |
WMS |
|
Sea |
|
YOR |
Yorkshire |
|
|
Coast |
(b) French Descartes map
|
FRENCH DESCARTES ABREV. |
NAMES OF THE AREAS |
OTHER USUAL NAMES GIVEN |
INDICATIONS |
NATURE OF THE AREA |
|
ADR |
Mer Adriatique |
|
|
Sea |
|
ALP |
Alpes tyroliennes |
Tyrol TYR see below |
|
Land |
|
ANK |
Ankara |
|
(*/Turquie) |
Coast |
|
APU |
Apulie |
|
|
Coast |
|
ATL |
Océan Atlantique |
Atlantique-Centre Atlantique Moyen ATM |
|
Sea |
|
BAL |
Mer Baltique |
|
|
Sea |
|
BAR |
Mer de Barents |
|
|
Sea |
|
BEL |
Royaume de Belgique |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
BER |
Berlin |
|
(*/Allemagne) |
Coast |
|
BOH |
Bohème |
|
|
Land |
|
BOT |
Golfe de Botnie |
|
|
Sea |
|
BOU |
Bourgogne |
|
|
Land |
|
BRE |
Brest |
|
(*/France) |
Coast |
|
BUD |
Budapest |
|
(*/Autriche-Hongrie) |
Land |
|
BUL |
Royaume de Bulgarie |
« Côte est » synonym of « Côte nord » |
(*) |
Coast with two coasts |
|
CAU |
Caucase-et-Arménie |
Arménie, Caucase ARM |
|
Coast |
|
CON |
Constantinople |
|
(*/Turquie) |
Coast |
|
COR |
Cornouailles |
Galles, Pays de Galles PGA |
|
Coast |
|
DAN |
Royaume de Danemark |
Danemark |
(*) |
Coast |
|
EDI |
Edimbourg |
|
(*/Grande-Bretagne) |
Coast |
|
EGE |
Mer Egée |
|
|
Sea |
|
ESP |
Royaume d'Espagne |
|
(*) |
Coast with two coasts |
|
FIN |
Finlande |
|
|
Coast |
|
GAL |
Galicie |
|
|
Land |
|
GAS |
Gascogne |
|
|
Coast |
|
GRE |
Royaume de Grèce |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
GRO |
Mer de Groenland et de Norvège |
Mer de Norvège NVN |
|
Sea |
|
HEL |
Baie de Héligoland |
Helsinborg |
|
Sea |
|
HIG |
Highlands |
Clyde CLY |
|
Coast |
|
ION |
Mer ionienne |
|
|
Sea |
|
ISL |
Mer d'Islande |
Atlantique-Nord ATN |
|
Sea |
|
KIE |
Kiel |
|
(*/Allemagne) |
Coast |
|
LEV |
Mer du Levant |
Méditerranée orientale MOR |
|
Sea |
|
LIO |
Golfe du Lion |
GLI |
|
Sea |
|
LIT |
Lithuanie |
Lituanie, Livonie LIV see below |
|
Coast |
|
LIV |
Liverpool |
LPL |
(*/Grande-Bretagne) |
Coast |
|
LON |
Londres |
|
(*/Grande-Bretagne) |
Coast |
|
MAN |
Manche |
Channel |
|
Sea |
|
MAR |
Maroc-et-Algérie |
Afrique du Nord |
|
Coast |
|
MED |
Méditerranée occidentale |
MOC |
|
Sea |
|
MON |
Monténégro-et-Albanie |
Albanie, Monténégro ALB |
|
Coast |
|
MOS |
Moscou |
|
(*/Russie) |
Land |
|
MUN |
Munich |
|
(*/Allemagne) |
Land |
|
NAP |
Naples |
|
(*/Italie) |
Coast |
|
NGE |
Royaume de Norvège |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
NOI |
Mer Noire |
|
|
Sea |
|
NRD |
Mer du Nord |
|
|
Sea |
|
ODE |
Odessa |
Sébastopol SEB |
(*/Russie) |
Coast |
|
PAR |
Paris |
|
(*/France) |
Land |
|
PAY |
Pays-Bas |
Hollande HOL |
(*) |
Coast |
|
PIC |
Picardie |
|
|
Coast |
|
PIE |
Piémont |
|
|
Coast |
|
POR |
Royaume du Portugal |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
PRU |
Prusse |
|
|
Coast |
|
RHE |
Rhénanie |
Ruhr RUH |
|
Land |
|
ROM |
Rome |
|
(*/Italie) |
Coast |
|
ROU |
Royaume de Roumanie |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
SER |
Royaume de Serbie |
|
(*) |
Land |
|
SIL |
Silésie |
|
|
Land |
|
SKA |
Skaggerak |
|
|
Sea |
|
SMY |
Smyrne |
|
(*/Turquie) |
Coast |
|
STG |
Canal Saint-Georges |
Mer d'Irlande IRL |
|
Sea |
|
STP |
Saint-Pétersbourg |
|
(*/Russie) |
Coast with two coasts |
|
SUE |
Royaume de Suède |
|
(*) |
Coast |
|
SYR |
Syrie |
|
|
Coast |
|
TOS |
Toscane |
|
|
Coast |
|
TOU |
Toulon |
Marseille MAR see below |
(*/France) |
Coast |
|
TRI |
Trieste |
|
(*/Autriche-Hongrie) |
Coast |
|
TUN |
Tunisie |
Tunis |
(*) |
Coast |
|
TYR |
Mer Tyrrhénienne |
MTY |
|
Sea |
|
UKR |
Ukraine |
|
|
Land |
|
VAR |
Varsovie |
|
(*/Russie) |
Land |
|
VEN |
Venise |
|
(*/Italie) |
Coast |
|
VIE |
Vienne |
|
(*/Autriche-Hongrie) |
Land |
|
YOR |
Yorkshire |
|
|
Coast |
ATTENTION : Following synonyms are rejected for ambiguity reason :
1. MAR will only be accepted for Maroc and not for Marseille (for this sake use TOU for Toulon)
2. LIV will only be accepted for Liverpool and not for Livonie (for this sake use LIT for Lituanie)
3. TYR will only be accepted for Mer Tyrrhénienne and not for Alpes du Tyrol (for this sake use ALP for Alpes)
Legend :
(*) : Centre
(*/country) : National centre for quoted country.